Download When Montezuma Met Cortés: The True Story of the Meeting That Changed History
You could rapidly finish them to visit the web page and afterwards delight in getting guide. Having the soft documents of this publication is additionally good enough. By by doing this, you may not need to bring the book almost everywhere. You can conserve in some suitable tools. When you have chosen to begin checking out When Montezuma Met Cortés: The True Story Of The Meeting That Changed History again, you can start it everywhere and also whenever as quickly as well done.
When Montezuma Met Cortés: The True Story of the Meeting That Changed History
Download When Montezuma Met Cortés: The True Story of the Meeting That Changed History
In some cases, remaining in this website as the participant will be so enjoyable. Yeah, checking out the book collections everyday will certainly make you feel wow. Where else you will see those numerous book collections, in the library? What type of library? In library, often, there are lots of resources, however lots of old publications have actually been displayed.
When When Montezuma Met Cortés: The True Story Of The Meeting That Changed History is attended to you, it's clear that this book is really compatible for you. The soft data concept of this likewise brings simplicity of exactly how you will certainly enjoy guide. Certainly, enjoying the book can be only done by reading. Reviewing guides will certainly lead you to always understand every word to compose and every sentence to utter. Many individuals often will certainly have different means to utter their words. However, from the title of this book, we make certain that you have understood what exactly anticipate from guide.
You recognize, as the advantage of reading this When Montezuma Met Cortés: The True Story Of The Meeting That Changed History, you may not just obtain new understanding. You will certainly really feel so fun and also pleasurable when reading it. It verifies by the presence of this publication, you can make use of the time flawlessly. Investing the moment when being at residence will serve enough when you recognize truly exactly what must do. Reviewing is one of the best means to do to accompany your extra time. Naturally, it will certainly be extra priceless than only chatting to the various other close friends.
ah, also you do not obtain the best perfections from reading this publication; a minimum of you have actually enhanced your life and performance. It is very should make your life much better. This is why, why don't you aim to get this book and also review it to satisfy your downtime? Are you interested? Juts pick currently this When Montezuma Met Cortés: The True Story Of The Meeting That Changed History in the download web link that we provide. Do not wait for more minute, the chance now and also set aside your time to choose this. You can actually make use of the soft data of this publication properly.
Product details
#detail-bullets .content {
margin: 0.5em 0px 0em 25px !important;
}
Audible Audiobook
Listening Length: 16 hours and 6 minutes
Program Type: Audiobook
Version: Unabridged
Publisher: HarperAudio
Audible.com Release Date: January 30, 2018
Language: English, English
ASIN: B0774Y3MSM
Amazon Best Sellers Rank:
To begin with what's new and convincing, the author builds a good case that Montezuma's "surrender" of his country, a major part of the legend about him and Cortes, may well have originated with a bad translation. To paraphrase the author's explanation, the English language equivalent of Montezuma's welcome was something like, "Let my home be your home." By the time it went through at least one and maybe two translations, it became something like, "I give my country to your king." The mistranslation was undoubtedly helped along by the Spaniards wanting to hear something like it.Another new feature involves seeing Montezuma as a collector. The author makes a good case that Montezuma collected animals of all descriptions including unusual people. Once Cortes and the other Spaniards arrived in his capital, he may well have decided to add them to his collection. Where I had a problem was with the idea that Montezuma wanted to "collect" Spaniards from the moment he heard about them landing in what is now Mexico. A variety of sources have stated that, rather than lure Cortes to the Aztec capital, Montezuma tried to bribe him to stay away. Once the Spaniards did arrive, Montezuma may well have decided to add the invaders to his collection, but it seems unlikely that he started out wanting to do so.So what else is wrong with this book? His view of Cortes fits that category. While it does give a reader pause to realize that Cortes had only one truly successful event in his life, the capture of the Aztec capital, the author tears him down at every opportunity. He comes across as, at best, a tool of the other Spanish commanders and at worst, a mediocrity without authority or a single useful idea in his head. Even Cortes's worst enemies never underrated him so much.Then there is the author's unwillingness to face the role sacrifice played in the Aztec religion. Justifiably he does question the claim that vast numbers of captured warriors ended up on Aztec sacrificial stones. Starting in the Classical world, European writers did have a fondest for adding zeros to any number they wrote down. That said, as often as possible when writing about the Aztecs, the author insists on using the term "execution" rather than sacrifice. He does this in large measure so that he can claim that the Spaniards killed more people than the Aztecs. That is very probably true. The trouble is emphasizing Spanish brutality conflicts with his next claim, that in the wars of the Aztec wars of the 1520s, the Spaniards were more or less along for the ride.The author's enthusiasm to see the defeat of the Aztecs as primarily a victory for their indigenous rivals leads to his claim that the Spaniards played a rather minor military role in the victory. Having painted himself into that corner, the author has no way to explain how the Spanish killed or enslaved vast numbers of not only Aztecs but other Mesoamericans as well and finally ended up in control of what they called New Spain. In fact the author doesn't even try to explain it.Despite these objections, the author has unquestionably done his research and has valuable contributions to make. Less special pleading would have helped communicate these useful contribution much more effectively.
To be honest I'm just halfway thru the book. Had to stop twice because the writing style makes it very difficult to get thru a chapter without having to yell out loud things like "yes, you've told me that a hundred times in the last 50 pages".It is obvious the writer fervently believes in his theory and 'facts',exhaustively repeating them over and over. And repeats them. And repeats them. And.....Another annoying constant is that the author is always indicating that a subject or reference "will be covered in a subsequent chapter", it's so frequent you want to scream -again!This is one of the most frustrating books I've ever (attempted) to read).
Matthew Restall is right: our view of what happened "when Montezuma met Cortés" has been completely distorted by 5 centuries of mythmaking, misrepresentations, and outright fabrications, all centered on the larger-than-life figure of Cortés. Beginning with his letters to Carlos I in the 1520s, and the hagiography of him by Gómara shortly thereafter, Cortés's central role in the Conquest has been portrayed as one of complete control and mastery of the events that led to the fall of Tenochtitlan. Even as historical interpretations of Cortés have changed throughout the centuries--from a courageous deliverer of Christianity and civilization to a brutally violent and genocidal warmonger-- he is constantly portrayed as a brilliant, yet conniving, strategist, with perfect information, and in complete control of the events.Restall's thoroughly researched book does two things brilliantly. One, he shows us, through what must have been an exhaustive reading of every narrative ever written about the Conquest since it happened more than 500 years ago, HOW the story became shaped and WHY it's been so hard to dislodge, even today. And two, he broadens our view of those events between 1519-1521 as they actually unfolded in the real world of Mesoamerican politics, a world Cortés had little insight into (his two translators notwithstanding), and even less control over.There is a lot of underlying humor in the book as Restall highlights some of the more absurd reimaginings various authors came up with recreating the narrative. I found myself chuckling many times as I listened to the book. I thought the narration was terrific, spot on.
Scholarly deconstruction of the Cortez story, one of my favorites in history. It helps, going into this, to be familiar with it already. The author makes a good case, I came away convinced, but felt a little sad to have the splendor, if that's the word I want, stripped from the familiar tale. One thing that kind of annoyed me was his insistence on calling Aztec human sacrifice, " ritual execution." Come on, dude!
When Montezuma Met Cortés: The True Story of the Meeting That Changed History PDF
When Montezuma Met Cortés: The True Story of the Meeting That Changed History EPub
When Montezuma Met Cortés: The True Story of the Meeting That Changed History Doc
When Montezuma Met Cortés: The True Story of the Meeting That Changed History iBooks
When Montezuma Met Cortés: The True Story of the Meeting That Changed History rtf
When Montezuma Met Cortés: The True Story of the Meeting That Changed History Mobipocket
When Montezuma Met Cortés: The True Story of the Meeting That Changed History Kindle
Hello, my name is Jack Sparrow. I'm a 50 year old self-employed Pirate from the Caribbean.
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar